Wednesday, October 20, 2010
The Purpose of Art
Here's Gary outside Stumpknockers, a local seafood restaurant. A stumpknocker is a type of a fish and a type of a boat. When I first heard the word stumpknocker I imagined it to mean a stump in the water which could knock a hole in a boat, or perhaps a stump in the forest which could trip me if I didn't see it, a literal meaning. It's a word which means different things to different people, like art means different things to different people.
Occasionally Gary and I have discussions about art. What do you see in the photo of him? What does the photo tell you? How do you feel about the photo? I'm not saying the photo is art, just keep these questions in mind as you read the next few paragraphs. I posted the photo and questions to stimulate the conversation a little. A bit of a ramble here, nothing heavy, just some fun and friendly discussion. Oh and the same questions for the next photo too.
Gary is reading Dean Koontz, From the Corner of His Eye and read me a quote. Enoch, the main character in the book, is attending art classes at a college in San Francisco and he relays this about what he is learning:
"The purpose of art: to disturb you, to leave you uneasy with yourself, and wary of the world, to undermine your sense of reality in order to make you reconsider all that you think you know. The finest art should shatter you emotionally, devastate your intellectuality, leave you physically ill, and fill you with loathing for those cultural traditions that bind us and weigh us down and drown us in a sea of conformity".
I can think of lots of art which has disturbed me, but I wouldn't want to think or look at it every day. So in other words, I don't mind seeing disturbing art in a gallery, but don't want to see it in my home. So does that mean I only want art that's "pretty to look at" in my home? Depends on the art, I guess.
The part about the 'drown us in a sea of conformity' I do agree with. In our world of mass production I like to see something a little different, something non conforming, something original, something handmade. Don't get me wrong I like the classics too, I like all art. Well maybe most art. Somehow, though, I don't agree with Enoch's view of the purpose of art.
I do think art makes us think, makes us feel, helps us to express ourselves whether we are the maker or viewer, makes us appreciate each other, makes us appreciate others' points of view, and should and does bind us together. I say, yeah for art, what do you say?
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I agree with Enoch with some art but not all, I think that's a very narrow point of view. I think art should influence the way one thinks and feels but I believe that happy is a good feeling that people should have. Maybe Enoch was just an unhappy person.
ReplyDeleteHi Lori, thanks, well it is a Dean Koontz book, but the quote got me thinking which I guess is a good thing.
ReplyDeleteI agree - that being disturbed is okay for some art. And I agree that our connection to art is emotional -- but art can also remind of us of happy times. It might just be a beautiful painting of a lake that reminds us of being loved or just colors that remind us of a contented time in our life. But art does cause an individual emotional reaction -- whether the piece is successful to many or not.
ReplyDeletei agree with Lori that Enoch's point of view is narrow. i think the finest art evokes strong emotion in the viewer be it happy, sad, comfortable, uncomfortable etc...
ReplyDeletelike Linda, I don't want art in my home that makes me feel uncomfortable... and i never did understand Damien Hirst's dead and dissected animals suspended in glass cases but he sure made a ton of money doing it!
I agree with you, Linda, art can make us question and think and its definitely not necessary to conform, but I am so tired of "the art world" telling us what we should think and feel about art. It's such a subjective thing. We each have our own perceptions. I like some very abstract art and I like some realism. Each has their merits. I feel Enoch's attitude was based on his own (the character's) perception of the world. Thank you for an interesting post.
ReplyDeleteA very stimulating post, Linda. I tend to agree with Teresa...and with the cliche, Beauty is in the eye of the beholder (which, of course, begs the question, What is beauty?)
ReplyDeleteFun post! What I like and what I put in my home often differ. In my home, I'm trying to decorate. When simply viewing art, I can appreciate what I think the artist is envisioning, trying to communicate, colors, etc. I'm personally attracted to bright colors and something that feels like it's telling a story or has deeper meanings...thus, Native American usually grabs me. Folk art also really interests me, as well as older western pieces...something with "history". This doesn't mean I don't enjoy abstracts. What I don't like are the pictures in the decorating departments of Hobby Lobby, Walmart, Penny's, Croft & Barrow, Bed Bath & Beyond, etc. It's like the "soul" has been pressed out of them. To me, they become flat and spiritless...kind of like processed food.
ReplyDeletewhen I look at the photo I was thinking "what happened to Gary's arm?!" hope he's OK ;o)
ReplyDeleteHi Judy, thanks, yes I feel that with some paintings, a calmness looking at them and I think I choose art for my walls that do that for me. I want to feel calm and happy or sometimes energized in my home.
ReplyDeleteHi Michele, thanks, yes Hirst's art is a bit much for me, but then there's the money he made, money isn't everything but it helps us to get through life and make more art.
Hi Teresa, thanks, oh I don't listen to the art world, the heck with them. I like both types of art too, abstract and realism, and often times just the color of art will draw me in.
Hi Kittie, thanks, yes I agree, beauty is in the eye of the beholder, and then what is beauty, oh boy more to think about. Sometimes my mind is working too much overtime.
Hi Turquoisemoon, thanks, yes I see what you mean about the art in the big box stores, good description that the soul has been pressed out of them and really they're mass produced without any soul, wonder if even the original had a soul, and then there's the point of seeing the same piece in someone else's home, I tend to decorate my home with pieces according to color or style which isn't the same as I would like in a gallery, so I agree there too. I used to have all antiques in my home, but now I have a more modern style so I have switched my style of art in my home too. I used to like more earth tones and now I go for more color and pastels and then there are my favorite colors of turquoise and lavender, which I am really drawn to.
ReplyDeleteI say YEA! I think clay is the one art form that you can get very close to.
ReplyDeleteWhat is more close then drinking or eating from a bowl or mug.
Hi Cindy, thanks, Gary hurt his shoulder two different times in the past, once in 2000 and had PT at the time and thought it was find. Then he hurt it again in 2008 same shoulder, same location. In 2008 the doctor said he could either have surgery or not, no guarantee it would fix his shoulder. My back was really bad at the time and we couldn't afford for him to be off work or out of commission. Since then he always has to be careful using that arm. Then the other day he cleaned the garage and unloaded the motorhome all in the same day and over did it so he couldn't use his arm at all this past weekend. It has to do with his rotator cuff and lifting things over his head.
ReplyDeleteIt's better now, but unfortunately all the old injuries come back to haunt you. Gary also has a bad back from car hauling and lifting non hydraulic skids that weighed 100 lbs for 13 years when we were first married. Both of us have to be really careful what we do physically, it's tough to get old in body and be young in mind. HA!
Hi Meredith, thanks, that is a great thought about ceramics, the art you can get close to, with all the senses involved.
ReplyDeleteI think a piece of art should be compelling enough that you want to keep absorbing and admiring it.
ReplyDeleteYour "Large Pyramid" would be such a piece!
Hi Ms Sparrow, thanks, I think you are right about good art being a piece you keep wanting to absorb and admire. Glad you like the pyramid. I saw the photo was rather dark so I lightened it up a bit and reposted it so you could see it better.
ReplyDeleteYour comment reminds me of the first acrylic painting I did for our last house to just fit the space above our dining room table. The painting was of just the ocean and the sky with a painted silver border as a frame around it. We couldn't fit it in our packing at the last minute and left it there and have regretted it ever since. The people who bought our house bought our dining room table too. I'd like to do another one but another will never be like that first acrylic I have ever painted. You can see it here, it was simple but yet we always looked at it when we ate dinner and imagined so much about the past, present, and future.
http://bluestarrgallery.blogspot.com/2008/09/whats-for-dinner.html
Great post! As an artist, I love art that makes me happy when I view it, and a subject that makes me happy while I'm painting it. Feng Shui says "if something does not make you smile, remove it from your home". I have embraced this concept for the past five years and believe that it has added greatly to my happiness.
ReplyDeleteIn the first pic, I noticed the sling, too. But what really struck me was how much Gary looks like my ex, minus the alligator! lol Omg, it's uncanny!
Hi Marguerite, thanks, you bring an interesting thought to the mix about having only art that makes you happy, art that makes you smile in the home which in turn makes you happier. I'll have to have a look around and see if that rings true in my home.
ReplyDeleteWondering was your ex named Gary too? Ha. No one mentioned that alligator, it looks very real but it's plastic.